
I was sitting on a plane on the tarmac for 2.5 hours and could not speak to a human by chat or by phone. My singular mission was to get to Dallas by any means necessary.
Since I was stuck on the plane, I couldn’t pick up and call Delta, so I had to use their messaging service. Of course, to my horror, the day had finally come…they discontinued their iMessage service and directed everyone to their in-app Delta Concierge Beta. A.k.a. Delta AI. And oh, as you will see, it is definitely in Beta.
But before you read further, please know I love Delta. If one could have a crush on a brand, I’m pretty sure my celebrity brand crush would be Delta Airlines. The point of this essay is to help you think about the implications of automation and that it may not always be the best solution.
As the groundstop delay was increasing, my aim was to get confirmed on a later flight.
I attempted to talk to an AI agent
After reaching out to the new AI in-app support from Delta, I received an all-too-obvious AI summary of my concern and request with a promise of being connected to a real human. Thirty minutes went by. Then an hour. Then two hours. No human ever came. The “concierge” couldn't let me get on a standby list. It wouldn't let me rebook.
Finally, we were airborne. I kept checking to see if there was a response from the bot. There was none.
Just shy of waiting 3 hours for a promised response, we landed in Atlanta. I immediately called the Diamond Medallion phone number and within seconds I was connected to a super helpful, human agent, Alex. As soon as he picked up, he knew my flight was delayed before I told him; he sympathized and helped me get rebooked.
The AI had guardrails in place that wouldn’t let it rebook on a flight that was departing within two hours, despite the fact I would have made it. Additionally, it was so narrowly focused on my arrival, that it wouldn’t change my airport. There are two major airports in Dallas: Dallas-Fort Worth (DFW) and Dallas Love Field (DAL). The AI concierge couldn't seem to understand that I would have been happy taking either destination. It also could not seem to find the countless seats on an earlier flight that I could book.
Here is an interesting question: Did the human treat me differently than other passengers because of my loyalty with Delta?
If so, was the AI agent just treating me on par with everyone else? And is it actually more fair and just?
It reminds me of that time I was being a typical Millennial
The idea of fairness goes all the way back to the playground. Who gets to go down the slide first or play with that toy next, etc. Our whole lives, we argue what is fair and what is not. Social psychologist Morton Deutsch synthesized three different terms: equality, equity, and needs. I’ll focus on the first two.
Equality, according to Deutsch, means everyone receives the same regardless of what they put in. In theory, this sounds nice, and many of us like the idea of equality. In reality, most of us subscribe to the theory of equity, which means we should receive based on what we contributed. The problem is, for companies training AI agents to go and do our bidding or be the frontline of our customer experience, we must pre-decide what is fair and what is not. On the surface, it seems like a simple task. The reality is much muddier.
Not long after finishing undergrad, I was in an executive role at a company. As I hired team members for my team, some had larger comp packages than I did, and I frankly didn’t like it. And, being a complete Millennial, I felt entitled to higher compensation. My CEO and I sat at a neighboring coffee shop, and I aired my grievances. He then told me a version of a parable he repurposed from Jesus’ teachings. To oversimplify it, several workers went out to work in a vineyard, and they all accepted the same wage. The catch was that one individual worked the whole day, another a half day, and the third barely worked at all. But they got paid equally. That is the idea of equality.
As my CEO and I sat shoulder to shoulder on stools looking out the window of the coffee shop, he taught me the lesson that I received or was receiving what I had agreed to receive, and I had to do my work for that pay.
So what does this have to do with AI, customer experience, and a ground stop?
Well, since I’ve already shown my Millennialness, let me keep digging myself in a deeper hole of entitlement and hand-out trophy prizes.
Why should a stranger care?
I've crossed their Million Miler threshold some years ago and am on my way to 2 Million. I'm their highest-earned Medallion Status and have been for years. That is not a humble brag; it’s context that matters…stay with me.
A few weeks ago, in my newsletter for professional speakers, I wrote an article arguing whether or not airline loyalty was worth it. My punchline was yes, airline loyalty matters because you could depend on your status to help you navigate tight or sticky situations.
It is a benefit of frequent flying I’ve grown accustomed to—for better or for worse. So, when the AI queue couldn’t direct me to a human, got stuck in a loop of summarizing my grievances slightly different each time and couldn’t perform a simple flight change task, I was pretty irritated. As someone who spends the majority of my time on the topic of AI, I decided to dissect what was happening. I started asking questions.
Would it have failed the first-time flyer the same way? Yes, it probably would have. So, the truth of the matter is that the AI bot saw me the same as everyone else. I was no longer “special” with my metal bag tags clinking around.
I absolutely believe that Alex treated me differently and was able to squeeze me onto an earlier flight because of my status. I have no doubt about that. But it is that status that would have earned my place as probably first or top of the list on a standby list anyway.
Whether you fly every week or you fly once every other year, the question isn't about loyalty anymore. It's about should AI treat everyone with equity or equality? I think most people's gut answers would be equality, but that changes the whole dynamic of how brands encounter their customers.
I think there's a fine line in a capitalistic society between favoritism and loyalty. But the question isn't about loyalty or favoritism; it's about the decisions that need to be programmed into an AI agent. These are far more in-depth and complex than saying, "There is a seat available" or "there isn't a seat available." It has to do with the agent understanding that two airports are in close proximity and switching the destination, in some cases, could be permissible.
Then it comes down to whether or not an AI agent should be trained with less strict guidelines for loyalty members so they have more flexibiltiy and agency.
Will AI level the playing field of how people are treated? Will companies like Delta have to figure out if they will give AI more latitude to treat its most elite and highest-grossing customers differently?
Not the groundstop you’re thinking of
Thank goodness I was home this past Friday night with my wife and three kids. After dinner, I went to the other room to check my phone, and it was overflowing with texts, notifications, and breaking news reports of planes being grounded all across the United States. My story came one week earlier.
While the nation is still trying to figure out what the root cause of that kerfuffle was, it's just one example of how reliant we've become on technology. Just a week earlier, I had my own travel nightmare due to another ground stop in Atlanta. But this time, my frustration and technology fail wasn't with the FAA or their routing systems. Instead, it was with Delta Air Lines' customer support system that was supposed to improve my experience but made it far worse.
Someone's got to decide how to treat people when they program AI. Artificial intelligence will never be able to intuitively know how to treat different people and how to weigh a scenario more heavily than another. Because a human has to judge if my reason for wanting to get on the next available flight is even valid. What is the consequence of them not putting me on the earlier flight?
I've often said that artificial intelligence could be a great leveling field. What I mean by that is people all around the globe, including those making just several hundred dollars a month, now have unprecedented access to creating and innovating that would have otherwise been prohibited for them.
But AI could become a great leveling in another way too. It could provide equality to everyone. While most of us would agree that we want equality, I think in our hearts, many of us lean on equity believing we deserve something or it is our right to have something.
In fact, that's what the whole American experiment was built on. It is our right to freedom, our right to free speech, our right to religion. While I don't argue with any of those, that mentality has permeated much of American mindset.
When everyone has equal access to everything, and more interestingly in this conversation, everyone is treated exactly the same by a machine, how does that shape our economy? How do brands have to revisit loyalty? Is this good for humankind?
Inspire Forward,

YOUR PERSPECTIVE
Last week, you said

We asked: Does how we treat AI carry over to how we treat people?

THIS WEEK
When an AI agent handles your customer service, how should it treat you compared with the company's best customers?
One tap. Results next week.
